HRA Agenda 06-02-2004
.
AGENDA
MONTICELLO HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AVTHORITY
Wednesday, .June 2, 2004 - 6:00 p.m.
505 Walnut Street - Bridge Room
Commissioners:
Chair Bill Fair, Vice Chair Darrin Lahr, Dan Fric, Brad Barger, and Steve
Andrews.
Council Liaison:
Roger Carlson.
Staff: Rick WolfsteJler, Ollie Koropchak, and Angela Schumann.
Guests: Brad Johnson, Lotus Realty Services and Barry Fluth, Master's Fifth Avenue
I . Call to Order.
2. Consideration to approve the May 5, 2004 HRA minutes.
3. Consideration of adding or removing items from the agenda.
.
4. Consent Agenda.
5.
Consideration to review a revision to the Contract for Private Redevelopment between Masters
Fifth A venue and the HRA for Landmark Square Phase II executed by the HRA.
6. Consideration to discuss for interest the establishment of a scaltered housing program.
7. Co nsi deration of an update relative to refinancing of the TI F Di stri ct No. 1-22 Bonds and to
authorize cal ling for a special I-IRA meeting.
8. Consideration to authorize payment of HRA bills.
9. Consideration of Executive Director's Report.
10. Committee Reports.
11. Other Business.
12. Adjournment.
.
.
MINUTES
MONTICELLO HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Wednesday, May 5th, 2004 - 6:00 p.m.
505 Walnut Street - Bridge Room
Comm issioners:
Chair Bill Fair, Steve Andrcws, Brad Barger, Dan Frie, and Council Liaison
Roger Carlson
Vicc Chair Darrin Lahr
Rick Wolf.<;teller, Ollie Koropchak, and Angela Schumann
Absent:
Staff:
1. Call to Order.
Chair Fair called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. and declared a quorum, noting the
absence of Vice Chair Darren Lahr.
2. Consideration to apProve the April 7th, 2004 BRA minutes.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY BARGER TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF TI-IE
MARCH 3RD, 2004 HRA MEETING.
MOTION SECONDED BY ANDREWS. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
3.
Consideration of addin!! or removing items from the agenda.
MOTION BY ANDREWS TO ADD AGENOA lTEMS 5, 8, 9, and 10 AS FOLLOWS
TO THE CONSENT AGENDA.
MOTION SECONDED BY BARGER. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Consent Agenda.
MOTION BY BARGER TO APPROVE ITEMS ADDED TO THE CONSENT
AGENDA:
5. Authorized cntering into the Contract fOr Private Redevelopment betwecn Masters Fifth
A venuc and the HRA for Landmark Square Phasc If.
8. Authorized paymcnt of HRA bills.
9. Accepted Executive Director's Report.
.
HRA Minutes 05105/04
10.
Committee Reports.
MOTION SECONDED BY FRJE. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Continued ~ Consideration to hear an updatc on redevelopment of Block 52.
Korpochak stated that she had received an email on 30th from a Walgren's representative
indicating that they are still interested in a Monticello location. They are continuing to
work on acquiring more property. Korpchak indicated that the developer realized thcy
would not mcet Junc 301h TIF deadlines.
Fair clarified that thisreport would indicate that thcre will not be any HRA Participation
cxcept for the possible sale of HRA property. Koropchak clarified that thcrc may be
potential fix a new redevelopmcnt project, which would requirc the creation of a new
district.
.
Barger inquired if bonds fi:)f the district would then be retired. Koropchak indicated that
would be the case. Koropchak stated that she is verifying final amounts of thc bonds and
will provide a report at the ncxt meeting.
Fair asked whethcr Scott Douglas had any comments. Douglas indicated that as long as
agrecments can be made with property owners rather than the H RA and City moving to
condemnation, he has no other comment. He commentcd that he still questions thcre site
plan as far as traffic and access. Fair indicated that those would be considerations fi:)r the
Planning Commission.
7. Public Hearin - Considcration to a rove amendin thc HRA Business Subsid Criteria.
Koropchak provided the staff report, indicating that on April ih, the HRA commissioners
had requestcd a public hearing to amend the Business Subsidy Criteria. The Proposcd
amendmcnt would alter Section 6 on Procedurcs to require a non-refundable fee
associated with the Preliminary Development Agrcement for TIF horn $5,000 to $7,500.
This amendment is consistent with the BRA's motion on February 4th, 2004, to increase
the deposit fee from $5,000 to $7,500.
Chair Fair opened the public hearing.
Hearing no comment, Chair Fair closed the public hearing.
.
.
HRA Minutes 05/05104
MOTION BY FRlE TO APPROVE AMENDING THE BUSINESS SUBSIDY
CRITERIA FOR THE HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY IN AND
FOR THE CITY OF MONTICELLO, PAGE 4, SECTION 6, PROCEDURES, TO
READ AS FOLLOWS: THE APPLICANT WILL EXECUTE AND SUBMIT THE
PREIJMINARY DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT ACCOMPANIED BY A NON-
REFUNDABLE FEE OF $7,500.
MOTION SECONDED BY BARGER. MOTION APPROVED UNANIMOUSLY.
11. Other Business
Koropchak noted that the EDA had approved the GMEF Loanfor WSf Industries. The
company had purchased and would be locating in the former Remmele Building.
Fair inquired about purchase of Chadwick parcel. Koropchak reported that May 10th is
deadline for Chadwick to accept the contract as proposed.
Frie inquired about annexation. Carlson and Wolfsteller indicated that the mediation is
progressing. The line of annexation is somewhat in discussion, all other terms seem
agreeable to both parties. The "No Hostile Annexation" group is a separate citizen
organization outside of mediating parties.
12.
Adiournment.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY BARGER TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 6:15 P.M.
MOTION SECONDED BY ANDREWS. MOTlON CARRIED UNANIMOUSL Y.
HRA Chair
Recorder
.
.
HRA Agenda - 06/02/04
s.
Consideration to review a revision to the Contract for Private Redevelopment hetween
Masters Fifth Avenue and the HRA for Landmark Square Phase II executed bv the
HRA.
A. Reference and baek2:round:
At the May meeting, the HRA authorized entering in the Contract for Private Redevelopment
between Masters Fifth Avenue and the HRA for Landmark Square Phase II. Since that time,
Barry Fluth requested a clarification of the terms for release of the First Disbursement Letter of
Credit and Second Disbursement Letter of Credit. He was OK with the rest of the Contract
but did not sign the Contract until his attorney had reviewed it. Fluth thenleH the country and is
expected back Memorial weekend. Prior to Fluth leaving, he requested this itcm be on the
HRA agenda in June.
A copy of the rcvision tfom the HRA Attorney has not been requested til after comments from
Fluth's attorney. Therefore, the revision will be distributed at the !-IRA meeting.
The revision does not require amending the Contract as it's for clarification purposes only. If
Fluth's attorney requests major ehanges that would be anothcr matter.
A summary of things yet to be donc prior to disbursement of the HRA dollars by no latcr than
June 30, 2004, will be preparcd.
Attached is a copy of the commcnts from the City Planner and Enginecr Consultants as
prepared for the Planning Commission meeting of June 1,2004.
At this timc, no action required.
.
.
6.
HRA A~enda - 06/02/04
Consideration to diseuss for interest the establishment of a scattered housin
program.
A. Reference and baek2:round:
At the request of Chair Fair, the HRA is asked to diseuss for interest the establishment of a
scattered housing progrmn. Some years ago, lIRA Commissioner Frie and Administrator
Assistant O'Neill drovc the city and idcntified potcntial rcsidential areas for redevelopment.
Attachment A. identifies those areas. You will note, the X represents the CMHP/HRA/City
Project completed in 2003.
One of the things that make redevelopment projects so difficult is the high cost to acquire
property. In conversation with Mark Ruff, I asked what other communities were doing if
anything. He noted that the City of Richfield continues with their housing program: to acquire
substandard homes as thcy come on the market. After demolition or determination to
rchabilitate, the parcel is put out f()r bid and sold to the highest bidder. Guidelines or criteria
must be established in advance.
With budget cuts, redevelopment grants are non~existence or few; however, low to moderate
income housing programs are still available. Richfield's program continues through the use of
pooling dollars from the Best Buy TIF District. Using a similar model, the Monticello HRA
could use pooling dollars on an annual basis from TIF District No. 1 ~22 for this purpose.
Allowable pooling dollars fl)r a redevelopment district is 25% ofthc tax incrcment. Ten percent
for administrative costs and fifteen percent for other. Or per Mark's projections Attachment
B.: 10% Admin = $423,486 and 15% Pooling = $513,784 or $284,475 NPV. !-Iowever, it is
not advised to designate the funds but to review on an annual basis as the 15% serves as a
reserve for bond payment in case of a tax increment shortfall. The bond projections assumes
full expenditurc of the Front Street project and does not ret1ect the sale of the property to Hans
Hagen Homes. Attorney Bubul is researching if these dollars ($297,352) arc outside the
pooling dollars and available as secd money Jor a scattered housing program. The second
source of funds would be the revenucs from a new TIF District eithcr Redevelopment or
!-Iousing District. A third Source of funds needs further research.
A better understanding will be defined at the HRA meeting after further discussion with Ruff,
Bubul, and WolfsteIler relative to the next agenda item.
.
If the HRA is interested to pursue a scattered housing program and has secd dollars, some
suggestions: Request an update of the identified homes by drive~by and by home value through
GIS program. Request research of possible thirds source of funding. Request drafting of
program guidelines or criteria.
HRA Agenda - 06/02/04
.
2
.
~1tQ.t.~W\."", t
A.
Elm Street and 6th Street
Neighborhood - Ruff Auto Area
713 6th Street West
. Owner: Laura
Rowland
. Value: $51,300
612 6th Street West
.
607 6th Street West
. Owner:
Ellsworth &
Doreen Grubbs
. Value: $50,100
. Owner: Duane
Gates
. Value: $29,400
613 6th Street West
. Owner: Paul
Dahlheimer
. Value: $29,200
c ~"""? I( ^ 0 tee. "t-
609 6th Street West
. .Unable to
detennlne
Correct address*
1
.
518 6th Street West
418 6th Street West
.
606 West 5th Street?
Owner: Scott &
Kristine Garvin
Value; $47,500
Owner: AdOlph
& Lucille: Benson
Value, $52,200
Lawrence
Tischner
$43,900
419 6th Street West
407 6th Street West
Owner: Paul
Schultz
Value, $56,400
Owner: William
& Donna Allen
Value: $56,100
Fourth and Third Street West
Neighborhood
2
.
613 4th Street West
725 3rd Street West
.
906 Broadway West
Owner: Malinda
Vickers
Value: $53,700
Owner: Roben
Barthel
Value: $59,100
Owner: Roger
Danielson
Value: $55,900
612 4th Street West
Owner: Dick
BondhllS
Value: 38,500
Broadway West Neighborhood
806 Broadway West
Owner: Steve &
Gail Maskow,ki
Value: B6,600
3
.
631 Broadway West
322 4th Street East
.
Unknown Address
Owner: Thomas
Perrault
Value, $49,200
Owner: Russell
& Sandra Olaon
Value, $43.500
Property Owner
Property Value
Comments
Fourth and Third Street East
Neighborhood
309 Third Street
Owner; Nancy
Hanson
Value, $100
tM.lY Want to
re--check Ulis as
t,q" book states
this as total
value?
Misc.
4
.
.
8 Linn Street
Owner: Eldor &
Nancy Jo"dan
Vallle: $46,000
306 East River Street
Owner: Robert
& Jessica Milton
Value: $42,300
5
.
City of Monticello
District 1-22 Projections - New Class Rates and 1.12 Frozen Rate
~'tto (. '^~~ t
~
Existing Delete Add Add Add Midwest Total
Year TIF Marquette Town Ctr, Hans H, Landmark" Graphics Revenue
2003 93,211 - - - - - 6,000 - 99,211
2004 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 - - 13,000 - 209,314
2005 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 - - 17,000 - 213,314
2006 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 - - 17,000 - 213,314
2007 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2008 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 1 7,000 - 233,314
2009 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2010 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2011 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2012 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2013 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2014 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2015 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2016 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2017 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2018 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2019 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2020 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2021 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
Totals 3,448,803 (225,631) 101,284 302,400 300,000 - 308,000 - 4,234,856
.
Debt Serv, Refunding Annual Net
Year Admin Cub Existing Bond Expenses Revenue
0
2003 9,921 5,124 59,125 74,170 25,041
2004 20,931 5,124 0 130,956 157,011 52,303
2005 21,331 5,124 177,180 203,635 9,678
2006 21,331 5,124 174,855 201,310 12,003
2007 23,331 5,124 177,080 205,535 27,778
2008 23,331 5,124 178,880 207,335 25,978
2009 23,331 5,124 180,225 208,680 24,633
2010 23,331 5,124 181,085 209,540 23,773
2011 23,331 5,124 181,430 209,885 23,428
2012 23,331 5,124 181,330 209,785 23,528
2013 23,331 5,124 180,765 209,220 24,093
2014 23,331 5,124 179,715 208,170 25,143
2015 23,331 5,124 178,160 206,615 26,698
2016 23,331 5,124 171,200 199,655 33,658
2017 23,331 5,124 174,120 202,575 30,738
2018 23,331 5,124 171,320 199,775 33,538
2019 23,331 5,124 173,220 201,675 31,638
2020 23,331 5,124 174,520 202,975 30,338
2021 23,331 5,124 175,065 203,520 29,793
Totals 423,486 97,356 59,125 3,141,106 - - - 3,721,072 513,784
PV-65% 1,959,945 284,475
5/27/2004 update district 22 for refunding bonds 2004
.
.
BRA Agenda - 06/02/04
7.
Consideration of an update relative to refinancing ofthe TIF District No. 1-22 Bonds
and to authorize callin!! for a special BRA meeting.
A. Reference and back~r()und:
In the last conference call between Mark Run: Ehlers & Associates, Rick Wolf.;;teller, and
myself, the decision to authorize issuance of the TIF District No.1 -22 Bond was delayed to
insure that the Landmark Square Phase II project proceeds. The bond amount includes
District No. 1-22 up~front expenditures including Landmark Square Phase I[ and District No.1-
23 up-front expenditures for Midwest Graphics. See Attachment A. The attached up-front
expenditures were compiled from a 1997 to current print-out of TIF District No. 1-22 from the
Finance Department and a cross check of the TIF Report to the State Auditors.
It is the recommendation of Ehlers and Kennedy-Graven that the City Council issue the
Taxable G.O. Bonds on Monday, June 14,2004, as interest rates appear on the rise and
because of the general public's knowledge of the June 30, 2004, TIF deadline date. The City
Finance Director, after an interpretation from Attorney BubuI, had thought about holding-off
issuing these bonds at a later date this year to include some other city projects with the
assumption of a savings in issuance costs. As the baUoon payment for the Temporary Bonds is
due July 1, 2004, the decision is to move forward now.
With the Council's action scheduled for Monday, June ] 4, the liRA should consider calling for
a special lIRA meeting on either Monday, June 14, 6:00 p.m. prior to City Council meeting or
any time prior to Monday, June 28, for the purpose to authorize entering into a Pledge
Agreement between the City and HRA relative to the bonds.
FoJlowing a conference call or meeting scheduled between Ruff: Bubul, Wolfsteller, and
Koropchak on the morning of June 2, the HRA will be advised as to the amount of the bond.
B. Alternative Action:
1. A motion caJJing for a special meeting of the liRA on for
the purpose of authorize entering into a Pledge Agreement between the City and HRA
relative to the TIF District No. 1 -22 and 1 -23 Bonds.
2. No action necessary.
.
HRA Agenda - 06/02/04
c.
Reeommendation:
Recommendation is for alternative no. I, date to be determined by lIRA.
D. Supporting Data:
Estimated up-front expenditures and Elher's projections.
.
-
-
2
.
"flF District No. 1-22 Expenditures
June 30, 1997 - May 4,2004
What Price Closing cost Relocation Interest
Hawkins House Acquisition $55,700 $768 $5,267
SchlieI' House Acquisition $20,000 $674 $1,635
Schlief CFD $63,000 $274 $12,017
Bostic House Acquisition $109,400 $2,117 $11,900
Car/son House Acquisition $275,000 $633
O'Connor House Acquisition $144,463 $~ "?
" J,JJ~
Pathway Improvements by Sunny Fre$ 16,340
Walnut St Public Improvements $11,212
Front St Site Improvements $114,455
Front St Public Improvements (Pathw) $ 24,600
Front St Public Improvements $23,184
Community Center $270,000
Landmark Square I $ 75,000
Landmark Square II * $352,500
Administration (Legal/Other Prof) $120,641
. Engineer $ 424
Taxes $ 7,114
2004 expenditures * $ 8,458
Subtotals $1,691,491 $4,466 $15,232 $18,919
TOTAL $ 1,730, I 09
District 1-23 (Midwest Graphic) $ 181,000
(land and site improvements)
* Approved by BRA - Contract not executed
* Expenditures through 5/4/04 per Kathy.
Does not include interest and closing payments on temporary bond.
-
-
Ollie Koropchak
Mark Ruff [mark@ehlers-inc,com]
Thursday, May 27,20048:14 AM
Ollie Koropchak; Rick Wolfsteller; Todd Hagen; sbubu/@Kennedy-Gravencom
Refunding of TIF bonds
From:
.sent:
To:
Subject:
~
m_l
~J
refunding of 01 GO update district 22
TIF Temp.XL... for refundi...
We should scheduJo a meeting or conference as soon as possible to
discuss the attached spreadsheets and following issues:
1. Amount of c~sh (from prior bond proceeds and district balance), avai.labJe for refunding
bond.
2. Tre~tment. of Hans H~gen J and s~ les proceeds J. ~bili ty L:o use funds for futurE'
scattered site !lousing by pooling from 1-22 4. Midwest Graphics st~tus.
Thanks, Mark
--.--------.---.-..---------- --.---.-.----
This emaiJ has been scanned for a 11 viruses by the MessageLabs Erl1a il Secu ri ty Sys tern.
.
.....
.......
Monticello, MN
$1,970,000 Taxable G.O. Tax Increment Refunding Bonds, Series 2004A
.
Sources & Uses
Dated 06/30/2004 I Delivered 06/30/2004
Sources Of Funds
Par Amount of Bonds
Unus~d Proc~cds from 200 I Issue
$I,970JlOOOO
JOO,OOOOO
Total Sources
Uses Of Funds
Total Und~rwritcr's Discount (1.500%)
Costs or Issuance
Deposit 10 Current Refunding Fund
Rounding ^rnount
$2,270,000.00
Total Uses
29,550,00
29.00000
2,209,12500
2.J25,O()
$2,270,000.00
.
....
refunding of 01 G.O. TIF I S/NGl.E PURPOSE I 5/27/2004 I 8:09 AM
.
City of Monticello
District 1-22 Projections - New Class Rates and 1.12 Frozen Rate
Existing Delete Add Add Add Midwest Total
Year TIF Marquette Town etr. Hans H. Landmark II Graphics Revenue
2003 93,211 - - - - - 6,000 - 99,211
2004 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 - - 13,000 - 209,314
2005 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 - - 17,000 - 213,314
2006 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 - - 17,000 - 213,314
2007 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2008 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2009 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2010 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 ~ 233,314
2011 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2012 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2013 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2014 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2015 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2016 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2017 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2018 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2019 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2020 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
2021 186,422 (12,535) 5,627 16,800 20,000 - 17,000 - 233,314
Totals 3,448,803 (225,631) 101,284 302,400 300,000 - 308,000 - 4,234,856
.
Debt Sew Refunding Annual Net
Year Admin Cub Existinq Bond Expenses Revenue
0
2003 9,921 5,124 59,125 74,170 25,041
2004 20,931 5,124 0 130,956 157,011 52,303
2005 21,331 5,124 177,180 203,635 9,678
2006 21,331 5,124 174,855 201,310 12,003
2007 23,331 5,124 177,080 205,535 27,778
2008 23,331 5,124 178,880 207,335 25,978
2009 23,331 5,124 180,225 208,680 24,633
2010 23,331 5,124 181,085 209,540 23,773
2011 23,331 5,124 181,430 209,885 23,428
2012 23,331 5,124 181 ,330 209,785 23,528
2013 23,331 5,124 180,765 209,220 24,093
2014 23,331 5,124 179,715 208,170 25,143
2015 23,331 5,124 178,160 206,615 26,698
2016 23,331 5,124 171,200 199,655 33,658
2017 23,331 5,124 174,120 202,575 30,738
2018 23,331 5,124 171,320 199,775 33,538
2019 23,331 5,124 173,220 201,675 31 ,638
2020 23,331 5,124 174,520 202,975 30,338
2021 23,331 5,124 175,065 203,520 29,793
T atals 423,486 97,356 59,125 3,141,106 - - - 3,721,072 513,784
PV - 6.5% 1,959,945 284,475
........
-
5/27/2004 update district 22 for refunding bonds 2004
.
.
-
-
8.
HRA Agenda - 06/02/04
Consideration to authorize payment of HRA bilJs.
At this time, no monthly HRA bills have been received Jor consideration.
.
.
-
9.
g)
HRA Agenda - 06/02/04
Executive Director's Report:
a)
Job and Wage Level Survey Summary - Attached is the covcr lettcr, summary, and
spread sheet of the 2004 Survey mailed to participating businesses.
Chamber Golf Outing - The Marketing Committee received 31 positive responses to
their gratis invitation. Twenty-six attendcd the May 20 event. Cost: $1,950.
Seminar for Manufacturers - Note this seminar and two of the featured spcakers
"Successful Stratcgies for Competing in a Low~Cost Manufacturing World". Are we
not proud of our industrics? Be surc to pass on a warm BRE congratulations.
Delano - Attached is a exccrpt for the State of the City power-point presentation by
thc Mayor of Delano at thc last County Partnership meeting held May 21. Notc; New
Dcvelopment - Industrial.
Elk River - The Economic Development Director call cd me after reading the article in
The Business Journal relative to Monticello plans to purchase land for industrial
development. It appears Elk River is in a similar situation as Monticcllo rclative to
marketablc vcrsus saleable land. Most interested in how we convinccd thc BRA,
EDA, and Council.
Economic Dcvelopment Director for Sherburne County - Resigned as suggested.
H~ Window Building - In conversation with thc real estate agent on May 24, he reports
they have one Purchase Agreement in-hand and expcct a second within a few days.
Price: $2.4 million.
WSI Industries - The CEO and CFO attended the Chamber Golf outing. Plan to start
moving in the first of June.
Leads:
1. ^ Princeton business looking to lease 3,000-4,000 sq ft of warchouse space.
Wouldn't leave phone number. Referred to Suburban.
2. Business looking for space to run a Spanish Speaking customer service center.
Lead from Wright County Partncrship. 10 new jobs first year and up to 25 jobs within
three ycars. $10-$12 plus benefits. They mct with TDS for presentation of services
offered by TDS and lookcd at leasing a portion of the TDS building on Thomas Drive.
They wcre interested in the Fingerhut building owned by Duane Schultz, Winkelman
Building Corporation. I met with Noel LaBine, Partnership Executive Director, and the
Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officcr of the company on May] 1. Noel
is assisting them to raise $5 million in additional capital. They appeared most interested
in Monticello's loan program. Although, the City has not received a loan application, it
appcars the request would not meet the guidelines of our loan program. If located in
Monticello, the company is looking for at least $300,000 in local support. I'vc bcen
talking with Duane. Looked at building twicc, company looking for $300,000
assistance from city. It appears Duane does have the building listed with an agent.
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
.
.
m)
n)
0)
p)
q)
-
HRA Agenda - 06/02/04
h)
Electronic control panel assembly - Lead from BRA Commissioner. This metro area
company looking to build a 5,000 sq it building with expansion capabilities. One to 1.5
acres. Currently 4 full~time jobs at $20~$28 per hour without benefits. Three
additional in two years at $15 per hour without benefits. 2004 fall construction. Monti
sites: Pheffer and Duane Schultz. May 25: Company feels Monticello to far out.
Added company cost as distance to customers and suppliers. Looking at sites in Elk
River, Coon Rapids, and two sites in Dayton. Schultz did not contact the company as
he's working on something else for the site.
Developer of MIR~guided laser technology - First contacted this Canada company in
August 2003. Talk to CEO the other day, he will call the end of June to visit the UMC
building. UMC has done work with this company.
Casino site ~ You probably read in the St. Cloud paper where Ryan Company was
looking for sites in Wright County. With no legislation action this year, project has
slowed. Executive Director of Wright County inquired about the Chadwick property
which was not mcntioned in the St. Cloud paper.
Aldi Inc. and United Property representative ~ I met with these individuals on May 12.
Looking for 80 acres to construct 500,000 sq ft warehouse, 15,600 sq it office, and
2,500 sq tl dispatch building. Total developed area 43 acres. 17 employed in office
and 35 in warehouse. 52 employees with total approx. payroll of $2,577,000 per year
starting June 1,2007. Knowing the City was in the process of acquiring thc Chadwick
propcrty, they focused their attention of the 70 acre site of Gold Nugget. Horst Grazer
not interested in selling. User not compatible with residcntial. Suggested Paumcn or
Osowski to foster interchange construction. Time frame: Purchase land Jan~Feb 2005,
begin construction May 2005 and open 2007. Trunk drivers are independent
owner/operators. 20 trucks in per day and 20-30 out per day.
Start up business serving patients with home medical equipment and supply needs. Has
space leascd. Applying for license. Looking for funding: Suggested Partnership or two
Sources through the Initiative Fund. Has equity and talked to lender. A Monticello
resident - supportive of his plan. Will kcep in touch.
Scheduled to tour Big Lake Industrial Park on May 28 with Feaski.
Production Stamping ~ Call cd and left message twice for Les Wurm. Trying to set up
an IDC tour of the company. No response.
Sunny Fresh Foods ~ Council approved concept and development stage PUD allowing
for expansion of an office/industrial use in the CCD district. The project consists of
new and remodeled office space totaling 13,800 sq ft on the f()rmer Methodist Church
site.
900,000 sq it distribution center ~ Lead MDEED. 550 to 700 jobs. ] 50 acres.
Would like south on Highway 25.
O'Connor residential relocation reimbursement - See attachment. It appears
i)
j)
k)
I)
2
.
.
HRA Agenda - 06/02/04
r)
O'Connors attorney's office found the lost check of June 2002 as was cashed in
March 2004. A second check was never issued by the City as a letter dated February
2004, noted the City would cancel the 2002 check and issue a second check upon
receiving reimbursement of the HRA legal fees occurred do to this immediate matter.
No reimbursement has been made to the HRA.
TOLD Company - I placed a cal1 to Bob Cunningham for an update of the proposed
Walgreen's project at the downtown site or elsewhere. No feedback yet.
Marketing Subcommittee is meeting Friday, May 28, 7:30 a.m., City Hall.
Otter Creek Industrial Business Park - The City Council authorized entering into the
Purchase Agreement with Chadwick for purchase of land f()r industrial development at
the Council meeting of May 24, 2004. See attached preliminary development
schudule.
Aroplax BRE Visit Summary. See attached.
s)
t)
u)
3
'tc0
May 18, 2004
MONTICELW
Dear Monticello Business Owner/Manager,
Many thanks to you, a business owner or manager, for participating in the job and wage level survey
conducted by the Office of Economic Development. I know the value of your time and busy schedules.
As promised and included is a copy of the 2004 survey summary and spread sheet (without business
names) used for tabulation purposes. The summary was divided into two categories: Manufacturing and
non-manufacturing.
The following businesses participated in the survey:
.
Groebner & Associates
Dahlheimer Distribution
Hoglund Bus
Maus Foods
Hospital District
EDMA
Custom Canopy
Suburban Manufacturing
Electro Industries
Twin City Die Castings
WSI Industries
Bondhus Corporation
UMC
NMC/Xcel
TDS Telecom
Hoglund Transportation
Dodge Dealership
Ford Dealership
School District No. 882
Integrated Recycling Technologies, Inc.
Tire Service Equipment Company
Rainbow Enterprises
Production Stamping
Aroplax Corporation
Standard Iron & Wire Works
Genereux Fine Wood Products/Westlund Distributing
Sunny Fresh Foods
Two un identi fied businesses
Should you have questions relative to the summary or survey, please call me at 763-271-3208. Again,
many thanks.
Sincerely,
CITY OF MONTICELLO
Ollie Koropchak
Economic Development Director
.
Attachments: 2
c: File
Monticello City Hal!, 505 Walnut Street, Suite I, Monticello, MN 55362-883] . (763) 295-27]] . Fax: (763) 295-4404
Office of Public Works, 909 Golf Course Rd., Monticello, MN 55362 . (763) 295-3170. Fax: (763) 27] -3272
.
.
...
.,....
I cat...")
2004 JOB AND WAGE LEVEL SURVEY SUMMARY
CITY OF MONTICELLO
In early 2004, the Economic Development Office for the City of Monticello conducted a job and wage
level survey. A total of forty-two surveys were mailed. Twenty-seven surveys to manufacturers and
sixteen surveys to non-manufacturers.
The survey asked for number of full and part-time jobs in each wage level. Two part-time jobs equal
one full-time job for the purpose of the summary. The wage levels ranged from less than $9.99, greater
than $10.00, $] 2.00, $14.00, $16.00, $18.00, $20.00, to greater than $22 per hour without benefits.
1. MANUFACTURING - 19 out of27 surveys were returned or 70%.
Number of full-time jobs
Total annual wages
A verage hourly wagc without benefits
Median hourly wage without benefits
1,357.5
Greater than $48,496,448
$17.18
Greater than $18, less than $20
IA. MANUFACTURING - excluding NMC/Xcel
Number of full-time jobs
Total annual wages
A verage hourly wage without benefits
Median hourly wage without benefits
947
Greater than $30,982,848
$15.73
Greater than $16, less than $18
II. NON-MANUFACTURING - 10 out of 16 surveys were returned or 69%
Number of full-time jobs
Total annual wages
A verage hourly wage without benefits
Median hourly wage without benefits
1,042.5
Greater than $37,153,314
$17.13
Greater than $16, less than $18
I1A. NON-MANUFACTURING - excluding School and Hospital Districts
Number of full-time jobs
Total annual wages
A verage hourly wage without benefits
Median hourly wage without benefits
354.5
Greater than $11,005,925
$14.93
Greater than $14, less than $16
FIVE LARGEST EMPLOYERS (RANKED): School District, NMC/Xcel, Sunny Fresh Foods,
Hospital District, and UMC.
.
'"
Qj
>
OJ
...J
OJ
m
rn
~
-
c
o
:E
"</"
o
o
C'\I
N
..-
~
^
o
..-
~
^
CD
..-
b')
^
"</"
..-
b')
^
'"
OJ
rn
S
m
o
f-
00000000000000000000
OCDNOCDCDOCDOOCDCDNOOOOOOO
o~mommomoommmooooOOoo
o"</"mOONVVONCDCDMNOrovroCD"</"
CDroVV~NNroV~roOM~OroCDro~"</"
ri~~~~~~~~~~~~06~~~~0
~O~CDm~NN~MCD"</""-"</"NroN~rom
~vmCD~~~M"-~oom~~NN..-~"</"
~OriN~~~~~~~~~~w~~~ 00
"-~~~~~b')~~~~~ "</"
~b') ~
'"
..0
o
"""')
m
o
l-
N
N
b')
^
~~"</"~~~CD~~ro~~~~CD~ro~N ~
O~OCD~"</""</"~~M~ON~~ ~ ~
..-M..- ~ V MM N ~
V M
..-
8~re~~~~~roCD"</"VVMVM"-M..-g~
M o~
ro
CD
~
o
~
~
N
~
o
N
fit
^
VNmmVVVMM"-"</"MNMN..-..-
..- ..- ~
ro
..-
fit
^
u)OMCD"</"N~NM""""""u)CDMN"-
NNN
U)"</"'</"roU)Nu)M~roM~CDCD N......
0..-...... N M
U) ~
u)'</"Nro~ro"""~~McoroVU)..-
~'(j'"~ T"""" u) M
CD~CDV~U)~OCD~~NNN......
,......., T"""',........
U)..-
o
......
U)N
~
U)CDNO......N..-CD
cD ,.....~
m M...... u)~
m N 00
m
!R-
V
Cl
C
";;:
::l
-
()
~
::l
C ;
w:E
M
~ U)......
00
......00
Om
o
o
o
"</"
v
~
~
ffl
0..-
0..-
0......
v
Ul.
ro
CD
m
~
fit
OU)
o .
.U)
Ov
v......
N.
N
V
ro
v
~
..-
o'</"
O,</"
0......
ro
N
M
m
~
'<i
~
~
o
O"</"
Ov
o~
"</"
N
"</"
m
U)
C'"i
~
~
OU)
OCD
0......
o
o
~
1;<)
"</"
~.
~
00
Ov
a:i
CD
..-
..-
M
ro
~
'"
OJ
m'"
rn.o
S~
~~
00000000000
OONro"</"CDCDOONro
cimma:ia:iojojoooj~
CDN~NmvCDrovI'--"-
I'--CDt-MNI'--rovvmM
~-Ol-Ol."</".......-U).ro.r:D..--~.C'"i
mVOlmCDO......'</"CD......U)
m...... Mroro CD NmCD"</"..-
rn- 0)- N~ T"""" ~- or-& "T"'""" ER- fh- ~ ,.....~
..-tFT!R-b')6'3-6'3-6'3- ~
6'3- W
U)~NroU)U)VU)I'--N l()
~tDroCDMMV'<i"-""" N
NCD CD"</" N "</"
VN 0
......~"</"room
C"?O')'T""" .,....
N
N~......CD
N("...j
......
......~~M"</"~
C") .
co
VOlNNNU)l.OmN
~~T"""" '\"'"cQ
~~
c.Da:)
..- N
~VMggs
OM
ro
ro
"</"
~
I'--
~
..-
~
"-VMgl()
.0
gl()
ro
o
o
"-.
N
W
~
Ol()
o .
.m
g((J
o
N'
o
co
~
w
Ol()
O'
.<;t-
01'--
CD~
~
~
o
ro
~.
w
t-CD'</"roU)~NMgl()
NOC
00
co....
~
co'
N
m
~
w
~~ro~O.....~~
M'<i ~..-...... 0
......M
~~mmm~U)~
c<i("...j ("...j~.,..:
'Ol"
VCO~U)~U)
~Ncrivdcj
N......
Cl
c:
.;;:
::l
ti
~
::l
C
~
:E
::
o
:z
..-0....
00'1
o
CD
M
..-
~
N
N
fit
..-Ol()
o .
.l()
gco
..
r:D
I'--
~
~
ffl
..-OM
CDro
M
/'-.
co
'<i
N
~
..-
w
'"
Q)
ml/J
(1l.l:l
~~
.
~G'Iii)
Once in a great while, an opportunity to gain a true competi-
tive edge in the marketplace comes along. You are invited to
attend a half-day seminar that will provide you and your key
managers with new perspectives, useful knowledge, and effec-
tive tools for succeeding in today's global business environment.
Through a mix of speakers, case studies and discussion, we'll
share key insights gained from our experience and research
with companies. Learn why some companies are highly
Successful when competing with low-cost regions.
.
You'll not only get the big picture on low-cost manufacturing
around the world, you'll also learn strategies you can leverage
to compete smarter in your world. Specifically, you will:
Identify the elements of your business which will increase your
competitiveness in this global manufacturing environment
Discover 9 proven strategies that successful companies use
to compete effectively with low-cost manufacturers and explore
the combination of strategies that might work best for you
Understand why China and other low-cost regions have
emerged as competitors
Learn how corporations are taking advantage of low-cost
regions, particularly China
Who should attend: CEOs and upper management of
manufacturing companies.
Sponsored by;
THE Btisi'NES'S JOURNAL
p:W1jvely
c/\ {1I111ttfr'1!/{
.....
(~~1JNNEAPOLlS
R r c! DN" L CJli1I!:h\:I'~.i C\)l,\!~JC:t.(~
RSM McGladrey
3601111 Educi'ltiOtl & Research Foundation is a 501(cl3 non-prufit corporation,
Featured Speakers;
Matt Kramer, Commissioner, Minnesota Department of
Employment and Economic Development
Ben Vickery, Senior Analyst. Manufacturing Extension Partnership,
US. Department of Commerce, Washington, DC
Melissa Kelly-McCabe, CEO. Clear Intent Strategies, New York
John Bondhus, CEO, Bondhus Company, Monticello, Minnesota
Don Tomann, CEO, and Randy Hatcher, General Manager, UMC,
Monticello, Minnesota
Event: Successful Strategies for
Competing in a Low.Cost World")
Fee: $129 before June 3; after
June 3, $149. Registration fee
includes breakfast. lunch, and
all seminar materials.
When: June 10, 2004
730 am - 1 :30 pm
Where: The Northland Inn
7025 Northland Drive
Brooklyn Park, Minnesota
Register: Register by calling toll-
free 1-800-298-3009, or online at
wwwminneapolischamber.org
and click on Chamber Calendar.
This event is presented by the 360vu Research & Education
Foundation, which provides a broad range of applied research
and educational services The Foundation was created to
promote the competitiveness of US manufacturers.
Inc.
.
.
-
New Development - Commercial
. Upcoming commercial projects
- Additional Delano Crossings development
- Potential Hardees site redevelopment
Former Hardtje.\' Site
,~/t>;
ano
nc Spilit fir CMtl/tlllfl;f~
Redevelopment Projects
Old City Hall Redevelopment
- Preliminary stages - development plans, TIF
- 6,000 square foot restaurant, market rate apartments (40)
Park and Recreation
In 2003, City completed trail
improvements along County
Line Road, Skatepark, and
8MX Park
Planned Projects for 2004
- Ice Arena wanning house
- Baseball Association
park im provemeots
j!~':~J.~B?0:, ,
Deli)'H;'
"n.c ,~p;,'lt"r Co,n"'/J"lt~
County /.ine Road Trail
~'; :.,~.~~~i~;
" "';"~':':<"i. "'-".
. .' ,', <, ~'. 'i'
'e'i:ino
T~;. sJh'tit /1( OMlIfIUtlit'1
9~.)
New Development - Industrial
. City working towards a new industrial park
northwest of town
_ Annexation contest has held up since 2002
- Possibility of200+ acres
- Provide additional tax base
- Increase jobs and local investment
- Provide opportunity for Delano
businesses to expand in town.
JJ$,.' ;'~~~.f:....)
rJEilono
"~II Spirit ",( CfMf/tl/ifldlj
Highway 12 Reconstruction
. Discussions with MnDOT ongoing
- March 16 Public Hearing at City Hall
- Presently: 2006 & 2007 Construction
. Municipal ApprovallPublic Hearing
- MnDOT needs to apply for City approval
- Issues: Detours, Accesses, Co. Rd. 17
intersection, lighting, landscaping,
other issues
~:r~;t.\
DelanO
'r~t '~f'(!t ~r CMlIfI~lIitl/
Infrastructure Improvements
. River Street
Interceptor Project
- In process
- Utilities complete
- Street to be completed
May/June 2004
Wastewater Treatment
Plant
- Add capacity
- ani ine August 2004
/
..
,,~,;: ". ..
.,:"" ,". ,. .~
-_.. ..".... .....~. .....
, "" ' .;: ';,'~ ~
iJ.";"'~'\;1;
~ ;",.. :,''i~'-'
, ielrino
T~~ Sf/fit o{ CfllltMIIII/t1
2
.
.
lL.O(l)
OZ<(
(j)<CI
lLJ I- I-
-(1)-
~::JlL.
<(,0
Z(I)f-
w-o:
o..~o:
w<(
I.-lO
f-OZ
a:~~
WII
Of-f-
Zf-O
::J<(Z
WI<(
0: f- , .
<(>-09
.....Ia:w~
U::J
w,o:z
oO:O:w
wow
;-o..UIJJ
q~)
.
~-~ ~,.........
! ;\:; -;-=-l ~}~ ~j
Li ;~i?~~~~~t:~i;(;~~S~~~~~
--
,./
H'> ;:? ~~) .~,
:';',D':!!::l.:0!.'i
:~:~' ~'::; J?:; ';::) \:~~
'e' 6~fj1',~ ~,~
~. ",,,,",,,
N "
!.~
\ ''<.,
~r\ W
0:
::J
~
W Z
~ C!J
o U5
;,. '~
~ITY OF MONTICELLO
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE
505 WALNUT STREET. SUITE 1 NO.
MONTICELLO, MN 55362
763-295-2711
Z~l
910 I
69323 I
MAROUErTo 8ANK . MON nCF.LLO . P,O, BOX 729 I
MONTICeLLO, M"'NESorA SS"62' (1(;"1295.2952 '
AMOUNT I
$],331.52
..--~ CHECK NO.
06/13/2002
THREE THO[JSAND THREE HUNDRED THIR.TY ONE
69323
DOLLARS
PAY TO
THE
OFml::R
OF
MICHAEL O'CONNOR
a
.,
.~----------~..,._~..~~
T '.;, ;/i::',:, :,~ I:,-~,';, :~,:,~.: 1.,:.:~...,:, '.:.,.1.:. '..,;.:,!I:_~Ei=:,..;:.",~~:'.:',.~",~.:.','.'....~:.1:~'.M7;1+;..'~l~.7~.c::I:.=.
..'I<-~ :::".:.i;;, i;: '~. '. " ',.., "'".
. ,,' I,.";? ,f':"-. ,.~
--~i~~i0t7,,~{:.;;::~__ )
1I-0{;g j 2 jll- I:Og.o .b{;L. 71:
7 {; 0 00. 7.ii_."n------~.n .1' 0 0 0 0 j j 1 . 5 2,"
.
February 9, 2004
Consideration to review negotiated Non-binding Letter of Intent and to
authorize preparation of a Purchase Agreement.
-
~-r:
INDUSTRIAL PARK DEVELOPMENT SCHEDULE
May 24, 2004
Consideration to approve Purchase Agreement for 120+- acres of land for
industrial development.
Establish goals t(n land acquisition (I:-IRA/City).
Development Committee begins work, (Covenants)
Marketing Committee begins work.
June 1, 2004
Closing - 35 acres released for Phase I known as haul road. $10,000 earnest,
$900,000 cash.
Chcck on grant for infrastructure improvements.
Based on mediation Annexation request.
Annexation completed.
After annexation
Zoning and plat approval process begins.
.
Authorize design and cost study of street and utility improvements for Phase I
& II.
Public Hearing - Amend the boundaries of the Redevelopment Plan of Central
Monticello Redevelopment Project No. I.
Authorize bids for street and utility improvements for Phase I and lift station.
Award bid for street and utility improvements for Phase I and lift station.
Fall 2004/
Spring 2005
Begin construction of improvements for Phase L
Timing of TIF District in relationship to construction of infrastructure
improvements. (City assess self)
Fall 2005 Completion of street and utility improvements for Phase L (Haul road)
November 30,2005 Hauling cease. (Prior to must lind alternate route)
June I, 2007 Completion of Chelsea Road Improvements.
'~~ .~ -y
iYJ........~
'i:J -::>
N L-c)VV'_'~-~
0:\._.
,,,
~(~_ ~/ vJ \ ~-L~ 6,
P-lw
C-L~
.
~.:?
~~
CJ....~
~ Q'),J-\-t--
~~ \2-~
s. 0 u-~
\':1,i\
~~ ~J. :;o,~ ~t~~\u~
~crv ,\0'\ ('~ ~ 3 ~ ~~
~'()'\ ~ \,~ \ t~'t
"V 0 YH:)~
10"d ll:l.LDl
-1- L I' I l.
----- ...L:..Q.oo-,. .<:;T
.
.~~"!" I
- // '- '-..... -.--..'"'-... ---. ........
,/J p_. '~
r7 c-
?7;
b ~ \- AA "" C9 .~ '-'-^ c1: ~- ~ "\ \ (1AA<:1
c:(\ '-\( ~rV\ l '~~ ~.~.~ '\ \; ~ i
Rm5.5ACR,S~~
I
~
" .
I
"-5GALE-.--
1 " = 500'
.a
......
\
).
"", '''\,
"
'-
"
'-,
Rf\N 5.0 ACRES
20.6ACRES .
1"'l.,'lIItn.'1""1':~".:'~~",'"I~' oiiii_ e"n'....,..n... ~.n.,~I'\.;: ...
I-:tt-,., I,-..~.,.-.r-.I
""l...IT C:::-::1 r HT,nC:C:H "X ~<:;f"l
91:n
.
.
...
......
--
.- .
-- ,,>
BRE VISIT
SCHEDULE AND WRITTEN SUMMARY FORM
.
~
q~)
IDC MEMBER
INDUSTRY
Name Lindquist an~
Phone
Name Aroplax Corporation
Primary Contact Steve Schoen. President
FAX
Phone 763~295-5002
E-Mail
E-Mail
Mai ling Address
Location 200 Chelsea Road
Monticello. MN 55362
FAX
Date of Visit
Mav 6 . 2004
Time of Visit
9:00 a.m.
Summary of Visit:
1. Looking for short-term warehouse space to lease - 10,000~15,000 sq ft. May expand
Aroplax building to the west in future. Suggested Kaltec or Suburban for lease.
2. OK to add web address: www.arol.lax.com
3. Employment - Under 50, hire some temporary. Busiest time between May and October.
Run three shifts.
4. Aroplax has over 100 customers. Their niche in molding is smaller runs. Very diversified.
They build molds and run parts. Have been continuously busy unlike some competitors whose
sales are down 30% due to work going overseas. Molding a dying trade due to young people
not interested in the trade and work going overseas.
5. Long-term plans: To retire in the trade at age 50.
6. Belief: Customer perception is everything.
7. Lindquist and Koropchak toured the facility.
DONALD BURR. the founder of
the 1980s low-fare airline
phenom People Express, is
back with a new idea: tiny jets
that will shuttle
executives on
demand bet-ween
small air-ports. He
even signed up his
onetime rival
Robert Crandall,
the former CEO of
American Airlines.
as an investor and
chairman of the
new venture, iFly
Air Taxi. BURR Quick, call
Moreover me a plane
,
.rmer hedge-fund
anager Julian Robertson has
onied up $4 million, part of
$6.3 million recently raised in
a convertible stock sale
disclosed on
SECOND ACTS
A PEOPLE
PERSON
FLIES AGAIN
says he'll have a consulting
role to CEO Burr.
Burr, 62, figures he can
offer a cheaper service than
private jets with a new
generation offour- and five-
passenger jets expected to cost
under $2 million apiece, far
less than current small planes.
He hopes to charge about
65% less than what someone
might pay to fly on
a private jet. Burr
says iFly will
"bring the private-
travel market down
from CEO level to
manager level."
The service will
take off next year,
with about 25 jets
in the Northeast.
Burr doesn't
expect to create
any turbulence for
the major airlines.
But with the fiercely
competitive Crandall on
board, iFly is bound to pop
up on a lot of radar screens.
~ Wendy Zellner
ING ERS
APRICEYWAY
TO GET
JOB GROWTH
USTRIES with tax
breaks is a boondoggle,
concludes a recent study by
the Economic Policy Institute.
The study found that state
and local taxes account for
only 0.8% of a company's
costs and pale in importance
next to the availability of
qualified workers, proximity
to customers, and the quality
of public services.
Tax breaks also sap
budgets for education and
roads. But the political
....-..!ividend fi:om bringing in a
Jctory or a new
'Theadquarters, the study's
authors admit, often trumps
economics. -Michael Eidam
141 BusinessWeek I May 3,2004
,
ANIMAL URGE
AD NAUSEAM What were they thinking? An ad
circulating on the Web shows the sunroof of
Ford's European Sportka decapitatinga cat. The
39.second video purports to be a Ford "viral"
ad, meant to create buzz. Ford insists it vetoed
the spot, proposed by an ad agency to give the
souped-up minicar a bad. boy Image. How the
ad got out is a mystery, and Ford says it's
"reprehensible." Animal rights groups are out-
raged, too. Yet the ad Ford did approve hasn't
fared much better: It shows a pigeon hitting the
car's hood and then lying motionless on the
street, angering bird lovers. Ford says both cat
and pigeon are digital-no animals were
harmed in making the ads. -Kathleen Kerwin
DRAWN & QUARTERED
lJIrn-..'t'IA\III::R '1tlf" '~~
l'n\ J.II'\.'t\.h..." <Q>zro<t. 17\\
'"
OJ
U
~
OJ
'"
<<:
;:;
OJ
:E
'"
z
;::>
<'1
;>l
""
......
~
OJ
Z
,.,
<
~
;::>
'.0
z-,
<OJ
:o:a
-b
"'......
,.,'"
l><:!;:l
"'>
-<
~~
'"
~