EDA Agenda 11-18-2015EDA MEETING
Wednesday, November 18th, 2015
6:00 p.m. Mississippi Room - 505 Walnut Street, Monticello, MN
Commissioners: President Bill Demeules, Vice President Bill Tapper, Treasurer Tracy
Hinz, James Davidson, Steve Johnson and Council members Tom Perrault and Lloyd Hilgart
Staff. Executive Director Jeff O'Neill, Angela Schumann, Wayne Oberg
Guest: John Uphoff — WSB & Assoc.
1. Call to Order.
2. Roll Call.
3. Approve Meeting Minutes:
a. Regular Meeting — July 8th, 2015 (to be provided)
b. Special Meeting — July 22nd, 2015 (to be provided)
c. Regular Meeting — August 12th, 2015 (included in packet)
d. Special Meeting — August 12th, 2015 (included in packet)
e. Regular Meeting — October 14th, 2015 (included in packet)
4. Consideration of additional agenda items.
5. Consideration of approving payment of bills.
6. Consideration of Market Matching report.
7. Consideration of an update on properties for sale.
8. Consideration to approve a License Agreement between the EDA and the City of
Monticello for use of 201 and 249 East Broadway and a portion of 100 East Broadway
for City Project 100009 /Intersection of CSAH 75 /TH 25.
9. Consideration of an update on the status and job description for the Economic
Development staff position.
10. Consideration of Director's Report.
11. Consideration of recessing to closed session to develop or consider offers or
counteroffers for the purchase or sale of real or personal property pursuant to Minnesota
Statute 13D.05(3)(c)(3).
12. Adjourn closed session
13. Adjourn
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING - ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (EDA)
Wednesday, July 8, 2015, Mississippi Room, Monticello Community Center
Present: Bill Demeules, Bill Tapper, Tracy Hinz, Jim Davidson, Steve Johnson, Tom
Perrault
Absent: Lloyd Hilgart
Others: Angela Schumann, Jeff O'Neill, Wayne Oberg
Call to Order
Bill Demeules called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m.
2. Roll Call
Demeules called the roll. Lloyd Hilgart was absent.
3. Approval Meeting Minutes
a. Regular Meeting —June 10th, 2015
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE THE JUNE 10TH, 2015 REGULAR EDA
MEETING MINUTES AS CORRECTED. TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE
b. Special Meeting — May 26thth, 2015
TOM PERRAULT MOVED TO APPROVE THE MAY 26TH, 2015 SPECIAL EDA
MEETING MINUTES. BILL TAPPER SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 6 -0.
Regular Meeting — May 13th, 2015
TRACY HINZ MOVED TO APPROVE THE MAY 13TH, 2015 REGULAR EDA
MEETING MINUTES AS CORRECTED. BILL TAPPER SECONDED THE
MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 6 -0.
d. Regular Meeting — April 8th, 2015
Steve Johnson commented on several administrative procedures. He requested that
information be provided in advance of meetings, that documents added during a
meeting be posted to the City's website and that meeting minutes reference
documents added to the agenda and issues which require follow -up.
EDA Minutes: 07/08/15
Wayne Oberg indicated that he does his best to get information to stakeholders as
soon as it is available. He noted that he generally produces data the same day that it
is presented. He explained that he has been ironing out past reporting issues in some
of the TIF districts.
Schumann explained that documents distributed at a meeting are included in the
official record maintained by the City Clerk but are not posted on the website at this
time. Jeff O'Neill suggested that staff update the online agenda packet in future.
Johnson asked about follow up related to the request tabled by the EDA in April that
some $200,000 in TIF 1 -22 excess increment be redirected to the EDA. Schumann
explained that the request was to be brought forward as part of budget discussions.
She suggested that the EDA may wish to discuss the policy questions involved and
make a formal recommendation.
Oberg distributed a worksheet detailing TIF 1 -37 and provided an overview of the
report. He described the review process involved in his analysis. He said that there
would be no excess increment within this district.
Johnson also asked if staff had followed up on his question about whether a
minimum tax valuation had been established for a particular TIF district, and if the
information had been passed along to the County assessor.
Oberg summarized that that Ryan Companies had challenged the tax valuation on
TIF 1 -34 and had it reduced. He suggested that it is unlikely that the EDA would
generate increment to pay off the negative fund balance in the district. Oberg
indicated that the City would absorb the deficit once the district expires.
Schumann added that TIF 1 -34 is a renovation and renewal district established to
fund I -94 interchange improvements. The EDA's attorney had determined that no
minimum valuation had been established by contract or assessment agreement with
private developers in the district.
STEVE JOHNSON MOVED TO TABLE ACTION ON THE APRIL 8TH
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES; AND DIRECT STAFF TO REVISE THE
MINUTES TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FOR EDA
CONSIDERATION. TOM PERRAULT SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 6 -0.
Special Meeting — April 8th, 2015
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE THE APRIL 8TU, 2015 SPECIAL
REGULAR EDA MEETING MINUTES. JIM DAVIDSON SECONDED THE
MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 6 -0.
EDA Minutes: 07/08/15
4. Consideration of adding items to the agenda None
5. Consideration of approving payment of bills
TRACY HINZ MOVED TO APPROVE PAYMENT OF BILLS THROUGH JUNE 2015.
BILL TAPPER SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 6 -0.
6. Consideration of Market Matching Report
WSB's John Uphoff reported that he'd distributed Monticello's Community Profile and
market information about available properties at several recent meetings and events. The
Community Profile was exhibited at the Economic Development Association of
Minnesota conference and was recognized by MN DEED representatives as one of the
best in the upper Midwest. Uphoff indicated that this places Monticello in the center of
the state's direct marketing efforts with site selectors in specialized sectors.
Uphoff said that he has been presenting information related to Block 34 as part of
networking activities with commercial developers. He indicated a willingness to assist in
preparing an RFP for Block 34 if so directed. He noted that he has also been networking
with several fairly large scale residential developers hoping to generate interest in pre -
platted areas and address the lot absorption rate.
7. Consideration of an update and approval of expenses related to environmental
study costs for the EDA -owned property at 100 East Broadway
Schumann summarized that the EDA is asked to fund costs associated with additional
soil boring(s), environmental testing, and coordination services related to contamination
found during property demolition at 100 East Broadway. This action would address the
Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) recommendation to determine the
parameters of the contamination and enable MnDOT to accept property for right of way
conveyance related to the construction of the TH 25 /CSAH 75 intersection project.
The location of the additional soil boring(s) has not yet been determined. The MPCA had
recommended that a soil boring be taken on the property to the south (Finder's Keepers).
The owner of that property, however, has not consented to allow a soil boring. Schumann
indicated that it may be acceptable to conduct soil boring(s) south of the original borings
on public property to the east and west.
Schumann agreed to find out if a similar contaminant had been found during the
environmental cleanup at the TDS site.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE AN EXPENSE OF UP TO $5,000 RELATED
TO ADDITIONAL INVESTIGATION AS REQUIRED BY THE MPCA FOR
COMPLETION OF THE LSI AS RELATED TO THE EDA -OWNED PROPERTY AT
EDA Minutes: 07/08/15
100 EAST BROADWAY. STEVE JOHNSON SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 6 -0.
8. Consideration to approve contract for July 2015 — June 2016 month -to -month
Market Matching Services
Schumann summarized that the EDA had voted to continue Market Matching services on
a month -to -month basis. The revised contract presented includes the current core services
and adds provisions for a monthly economic development e -news and Market Matching
activity updates at monthly EDA meetings. WSB also added a 30 day notice of
termination clause. The contract will continue at the current $4,000 monthly rate. This
expense is included through 2015 within the EDA's General Fund budget.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE THE MONTH -TO -MONTH CONTRACT
FOR MARKET MATCHING SERVICES WITH WSB & ASSOCIATES AS
PREPARED. STEVE JOHNSON SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 6-
0.
9. Consideration to set a ioint EDA /City Council work session for purposes of
EDA/HRA Lew discussions
STEVE JOHNSON MOVED TO CALL FOR A SPECIAL MEETING OF THE EDA
ON JULY 22ND, 2015 AT 4:30 PM FOR PURPOSES OF EDA AND HRA LEVY
DISCUSSIONS. BILL TAPPER SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 6-
0.
10. Economic Development Director's Report
Schumann provided updates related to the economic development position, property for
sale, the Hospitality Study and TIF training. Jeff O'Neill reported on the MN Public
Utilities Commission's decision to cap the solar garden project size at 5 megawatts.
11. Adjournment
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 7:20 PM. TOM
PERRAULT SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 6 -0.
Recorder: Kerry Burri
Approved:
Attest:
EDA Representative
4
MINUTES
SPECIAL MEETING - ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Wednesday, July 22, 2015 — 4:30 PM, Monticello Community Center
Present: Bill Demeules, Bill Tapper, Tracy Hinz, Jim Davidson, Steve Johnson, Tom
Perrault
Absent: Lloyd Hilgart
Others: Angela Schumann, Jeff O'Neill, Wayne Oberg
Call to Order
Bill Demeules called the meeting to order at 4:30 p.m.
2. Roll Call
Demeules called the roll. Lloyd Hilgart was not present.
3. EDA \HRA Lew
Demeules noted that the purpose of the meeting is to discuss the EDA/HRA levy. Angela
Schumann added that this discussion would enable the EDA to begin to formulate a levy
recommendation for City Council consideration by the September 15th levy filing
deadline.
Schumann provided a brief overview of each type of levy and responded to questions and
comments. She recommended that the commissioners refer to the Kennedy & Graven
memo included in the agenda packet for more detailed information about how the levies
function and the process involved in establishing a levy.
Schumann explained that a HRA levy is to be used for housing and redevelopment
activities. She pointed out that most cities that have established a HRA levy, however,
use it to fund all of their economic development needs.
Schumann said that Wayne Oberg prefers that the EDA establish a HRA levy and
recommends that the levy be used to fund the EDA's annual operating expenses.
Schumann also mentioned that Oberg had suggested that a HRA levy would have a
relatively small impact on individual homes.
There was considerable discussion about the extent to which the EDA should intervene to
enable downtown redevelopment. There were comments related to the need to level the
playing field to prompt development when the market does not seem to be driving
development.
There was also much discussion about how to frame the recommendation to levy so that
Special EDA Minutes: 07/22/15
it establishes the need for funding as well as the benefit of funding. Schumann pointed
out that the EDA could opt to levy for the cost of annual operating expenses only or opt
to levy for operating expenses and the estimated cost of economic development priorities
identified in the workplan. She noted that the EDA also has the option of recommending
both an EDA and an HRA levy to address funding needs.
Schumann agreed to provide additional information in an effort to help the EDA
determine and prepare its levy recommendation. The information requested includes
budget estimates pertaining to redevelopment project priorities, existing and anticipated
resources, expected shortfall, and options to address the funding gap.
STEVE JOHNSON MOVED TO DIRECT STAFF TO PREPARE ITEMS 1 -5 FOR
REVIEW AT A 4:30 PM SPECIAL MEETING (WORKSHOP) PRIOR TO THE
AUGUST 12TH 2015 EDA MEETING. TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE MOTION.
MOTION CARRIED 5 -0. (Bill Tapper was not present to vote.)
4. Adiourn
TRACY HINZ MOVED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 6:07 PM. TOM
PERRAULT SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 5 -0. (Bill Tapper was
not present to vote.)
Recorder: Kerry Burri
Approved:
Attest:
Angela Schumann, Community Development Director
2
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING - ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (EDA)
Wednesday, August 12, 2015, Mississippi Room, Monticello Community Center
Present: Bill Demeules, Bill Tapper, Tracy Hinz, Jim Davidson, Steve Johnson, Tom
Perrault, Lloyd Hilgart
Absent: None
Others: Angela Schumann, Jeff O'Neill, Wayne Oberg
1. Call to Order
Bill Demeules called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m.
2. Roll CaII
Demeules called the roll. All commissioners were present.
3. Approval of Minutes
Bill Demeules indicated that the following meeting minutes would be included with the
September agenda.
a. Regular Meeting - April Sth, 2015
b. Regular Meeting - July 8th, 2015
c. Special Meeting - July 22nd, 2015
4. Consideration of adding items to the agenda None
5. Consideration of approving payment of bills
Tracy Hinz asked for information related to the $12,000 expenditure for return of excess
TIF payment. Angela Schumann agreed to report back with a response.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE PAYMENT OF BILLS THROUGH JULY
2015. TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7-0.
6. Consideration of Market Matching report
WSB's John Uphoff reported the following Market Matching activities:
• Met with industrial developer Grady Kinghom
• Met with prospect regarding leasing space for light industrial business expansion
• Responding to Greater MSP's RFI related to a 10-20 acre site for a bio -tech firm
EDA Minutes: 08/12/15
• Reached out to Director of Operations at David Weekly Homes
• Marketing industrial properties and certified shovel ready sites through magazine
• Followed up with prospects for Cedar Street Garden and Fred's Auto properties
• Preparing MN DEED Familiarization Tour
• Attended Midwest Chapter of CoreNet Global annual meeting
• Provided commercial and industrial data for local broker
7. Consideration to adopt Resolution #EDA -2015-007 approve final payment to Veit &
Company, Inc. for abatement and demolition services at 100 East Broadway
Angela Schumann reported that WSB reviewed the contract and completed work for the
abatement and demolition of 100 East Broadway and recommended final payment to Veit
& Company, Inc. in the amount of $2,635.30. Veit & Company provided final project
paperwork and completed the repair of the parking lot on the adjacent property to the
satisfaction of the property owner.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO ADOPT RESOLUTION #EDA -2015-007 APPROVING A
10% PAYMENT OF $2,625.30 TO VEIT & COMPANY, INC. FOR ABATEMENT
AND DEMOLITION SERVICES AT 100 EAST BROADWAY. STEVE JOHNSON
SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7-0.
S. Consideration of approving funding for 2015 Industry of Year/MN Manufacturer's
Week activities
TRACY HINZ MOVED TO APPROVE FUNDING FOR THE 2015 INDUSTRY OF
THE YEAR EVENT. BILL TAPPER SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 7-0.
9. Consideration to set a ioint EDA/City Council work session for purposes of
EDA/HRA Levy and budget discussions
TRACY HINZ MOVED TO CALL FOR A SPECIAL MEETING OF THE EDA ON
AUGUST 24TH, 2015 AT 5:30 PM FOR PURPOSES OF EDA AND HRA LEVY
DISCUSSIONS, AND TO REQUEST ATTENDANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL.
STEVE JOHNSON SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7-0.
10. Consideration of a recommendation regarding a proposed EDA staff position for
2016
Schumann presented rationale for re-establishing the economic development staff
position eliminated in August of 2012. She explained that activities have been delayed
and response times increased as a result of limited staff time and resources available to
address economic development. She pointed out that hiring a dedicated economic
development professional would result in improved management of the day to day
operational workload and proactive efforts toward addressing the strategic initiatives
identified in the EDA workplan.
Schumann indicated that EDA small group appointees Lloyd Hilgart and Jim
Davidson support re-establishing an economic development position based on an in-
depth review of the proposal. The $48,000 budgeted for Market Matching would be
reallocated to cover a portion of the cost of funding the staff position.
Tom Perrault indicated that he would vote against the proposal because he thought that, if
the City hires a Business Manager for FiberNet, Communications Coordinator Rachel
Leonard would have time to fill some of the voids related to communication, once she
has transitioned from her current role at FiberNet. Schumann suggested that there is
ample workload to justify both positions.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO RECOMMEND TO THE CITY COUNCIL THAT THE
CITY PROCEED WITH ESTABLISHMENT AND HIRING OF A FULL-TIME EDA
STAFF POSITION FOR 2016. JIM DAVIDSON SECONDED THE MOTION.
MOTION CARRIED 6-1 WITH TOM PERRAULT VOTING IN OPPOSITION.
11. Consideration of an update on amendments to the Small Cities Economic
Development Set -Aside Revolving Loan Fund Guidelines
Schumann summarized a series of amendments to the Small Cities Economic
Development Set -Aside Revolving Loan Fund guidelines based on discussion with MN
DEED. The amendments include a clarification to compliance requirements, revised
language related to public-private financing and a reference to federal guidelines.
Schumann pointed out that the guidelines for application do not require EDA approval.
Final amendments will be considered by the City Council. Schumann said that she would
look into redirecting legal fees to Council as it administers the funding for this program.
12. Consideration of direction regarding available pooled housing increment,
Monticello Tax Increment Financing District 1-22
Schumann summarized that the EDA has the option of pooling an additional 10% of tax
increment within TIF 1-22 to fund a qualified housing project within the redevelopment
area. She noted that this would generate $345,000 over the life of the district.
Schumann indicated that she would confirm that the EDA would be able to capitalize the
annual revenue through an interfund TIF loan. She also said that she would confirm that
the pooled funds would be available to use for this purpose after the district decertifies.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO DIRECT EDA STAFF AND FINANCIAL
CONSULTANTS TO BEGIN THE MODIFICATION OF TIF DISTRICT 1-22 AS
RELATED TO THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A 10% POOLING ALLOWANCE FOR
HOUSING. TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7-0.
13. Economic Development Report
Schumann responded to questions and provided further details related to updates
involving Landmark Square II/TIF 1-35 and the TH 25/CSAH 75 preliminary schedule.
14. Adiournment
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 6:55 PM. TOM
PERRAULT SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7-0.
Recorder: Kerry Burri
Approved:
Attest:
EDA Representative
4
MINUTES
SPECIAL MEETING - ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Wednesday, August 12, 2015, 4:30 PM - Monticello Community Center
Present: Bill Demeules, Bill Tapper, Tracy Hinz, Jim Davidson, Steve Johnson, Tom
Perrault, Lloyd Hilgart
Absent: None
Others: Angela Schumann, Jeff O'Neill, Wayne Oberg
Call to Order
Bill Demeules called the special meeting to order at 4:30 p.m.
2. Roll Call
Bill Demeules called the roll. All EDA commissioners were present.
3. Purpose
The purpose of the special meeting is to discuss the option of recommending an
EDA/HRA Levy.
Angela Schumann pointed out that the Wright County deadline to file a levy is September
15th. She proposed that the EDA invite City Council input at a joint meeting on August
24th and plan to recommend action at the September 9th EDA meeting. This schedule
would enable Council to make a levy decision at its September 14th meeting.
Schumann explained that the EDA had requested additional information related to
various financial considerations to help frame the levy discussion in preparation for the
workshop with the City Council. She provided some level of detail related to each area
and responded to questions.
Schumann reported that Block 34 has cost $1,713,000 to -date. Schumann estimated that
it would cost $1,793,000 to acquire and control four additional parcels. The total Block
34 cost is estimated to be $3,400,000. Schumann also estimated $2,306,600 for Block 35,
$1,565,500 for Block 52, and $757,600 for Block 53, based on CMV acquisition costs.
Schumann outlined the proposed 2016 EDA operating budget. She explained that the
$140,000 budget would fund the EDA Director position, additional staff training, limited
funding for Market Matching, and the TIF Management Plan.
Schumann provided an overview of existing financial resources. She noted increment
generated in TIF Districts 1 -30 and 1 -39 and interest earnings on the GMEF balance. She
mentioned that revenue generated through the farm lease is offset by the taxes paid on the
Special EDA Minutes: 08/12/15
land farmed.
Schumann explained that the EDA has a total of $2,500,000 available including the
General Fund balance, increment from TIF 1 -6, and cash flow from TIF 1 -22. She
pointed out that this revenue will fund operations through 2022.
There was much discussion related to how to summarize funding limitations. Schumann
pointed out that the cash flow analysis presented includes $3,224,000 in land held for
resale and TIF funding subject to housing expenditure restrictions. She proposed listing
these resources separately so that the cash flow projection more clearly identifies funding
actually available. She also suggested listing land that the EDA wants to sell separately.
There was some discussion about the various benefits of establishing a levy. There
seemed to be general agreement that a levy would enable the EDA to achieve its goals.
Schumann explained that the City Council would retain oversight and approvals related
to the EDA budget, modifying TIF districts, and EDA workplan ratification. She
suggested that the EDA may wish to provide further accountability by formalizing joint
meetings related to the purchase or sale of property and providing a year -end EDA
activities report subject to Council approval.
4. Adiournment
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO ADJOURN THE SPECIAL MEETING AT 5:52 PM.
TOM PERRAULT SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7 -0.
Recorder: Kerry Burn
Approved:
Attest:
Angela Schumann, Community & Economic Development Director
2
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING - ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (EDA)
Wednesday, October 141, 2015 - Mississippi Room, Monticello Community Center
Present: Bill Demeules, Bill Tapper, Tracy Hinz, Jim Davidson, Steve Johnson, Tom
Perrault, Lloyd Hilgart
Absent: None
Others: Angela Schumann, Jeff O'Neill, Wayne Oberg
(Fall to Order
Bill Demeules called the meeting to order at 6 p.m.
2. Roll Call
Bill Demeules called the roll. All commissioners were present.
3. Approval of Minutes
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE THE APRIL 8TH, 2015 REGULAR MEETING
MINUTES AS CORRECTED. TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 7 -0.
TOM PERRAULT MOVED TO TABLE ACTION ON THE JULY 8TH, 2015
REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, THE JULY 22ND, 2015 SPECIAL MEETING
MINUTES, THE AUGUST 12TH, 2015 REGULAR MEETING MINUTES AND THE
AUGUST 12TH, 2015 SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES AS THESE WERE NOT YET
AVAILABLE FOR CONSIDERATION. TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE MOTION.
MOTION CARRIED 7 -0.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE THE AUGUST 24TH, 2015, SPECIAL
MEETING MINUTES. STEVE JOHNSON SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 7 -0.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE THE SEPTEMBER 9TH, 2015 REGULAR
MEETING MINUTES AS CORRECTED. TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE MOTION.
MOTION CARRIED 7 -0.
4. Consideration of adding items to the agenda
• Reschedule EDA Meeting
• City Use of EDA Property
EDA Minutes: 10/14/15
5. Consideration of approving payment of bills
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE PAYMENT OF BILLS THROUGH
SEPTEMBER 2015. LLOYD HILGART SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 7 -0.
6. Consideration of Market Matching report
WSB consultant John Uphoff reported on the following Market Matching activities:
• Wright County Economic Development Partnership (WCEDP) State of the Cities
Meeting — Monticello is experiencing moderate growth in the residential and commercial
sectors. Industrial sector growth has lagged throughout the county.
• MN DEED Familiarization Tour — Monticello`s profile and market data reports were
distributed to site selectors, including those working with Fortune 500 clients.
• Hotel Market Study Response — Three hotel developers engaged in early discussions.
WSB organized a pre - development meeting with a developer. The developer has since
discussed project parameters with investors.
7. Consideration to adopt Resolution EDA- 2015 -010 for the modification of Tax Increment
Financing District No. 1 -22 as related to tax increment pooling for housing
Angela Schumann recommended that the EDA modify the TIF 1 -22 Plan in order to capture
the additional 10% of pooled housing increment allowable. She explained that doing so would
enable the EDA to borrow against an estimated $345,000 in future increment if it has
committed to funding a qualified housing project before decertification of the district in 2024.
TRACY HINZ MOVED TO ADOPT RESOLUTION EDA -2015 -010 APPROVING
MODIFICATION OF TAX INCREMENT FINANCING PLAN FOR TAX INCREMENT
FINANCING DISTRICT NO. 1 -22. BILL TAPPER SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 7 -0.
8. Consideration of authorizing a 2016 contribution to the Initiative Foundation
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO APPROVE CONTRIBUTING $2,300 OF THE 2016 EDA
GENERAL FUND TO THE INITIATIVE FOUNDATION. LLOYD HILGART
SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 6 -1 WITH TOM PERRAULT VOTING
IN OPPOSITION.
Tom Perrault voted in opposition because there was no fund matching commitment.
9. Consideration of review and action as related to TIF 1 -35
Angela Schumann explained that TIF 1 -35 involves a parcel located at 3rd and Locust which
was to be developed as a retail commercial project. The district was created to generate
increment to reimburse the developer for land acquisition costs. The contract for private
EDA Minutes: 10/14/15
redevelopment had been amended twice to delay the start of the project and minimum
improvement dates. The knock down requirement and five -year rule have been met. The tax
increment has been obligated but has not yet been generated. Schumann said that she would
verify that a change to the scope or nature of the development would not impact the
obligation created to satisfy the three -year window requirement.
Barry Fluth introduced himself as President of Masters 5th Avenue, Inc. and owner of the
property. He explained that he had explored retail\housing, daycare and office options over
the years in an effort to develop the property. Fluth indicated that he is open to ideas.
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO TABLE THIS ITEM AND TO DIRECT STAFF TO
RESEARCH ADDITIONAL OPTIONS WITH THE DEVELOPER AND THE EDA
ATTORNEY. STEVE JOHNSON SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7 -0.
10. Consideration to set dates for 2016 goal- setting workshop(s) of the EDA
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO SET A SPECIAL MEETING DATE OF WEDNESDAY,
NOVEMBER 18TH AT 4:30 PM FOR A 2016 EDA GOAL - SETTING WORKSHOP TO
BE FOLLOWED BY THE RESCHEDULED REGULAR EDA MEETING AT 6 PM.
TRACY HINZ SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION CARRIED 7 -0.
11. Consideration of adding items to the agenda
• Reschedule EDA Meeting — This item is addressed as part of item 10.
• City Use of EDA Property - Schumann explained that the City had requested use of
the Cedar Street Garden Center site and the Block 34 site for storage and mobilization
during the Highway 25 /CSAH 75 Intersection Improvement project. She agreed to
confirm that this would not impact the Cedar Street parking agreement. Schumann
also said that she'd prepare a license agreement, to include a termination provision
should the sites be sold, for EDA consideration.
12. Consideration of Director's Report
• Industry of the Year Update — Schumann encouraged EDA members to attend the
2015 Industry of the Year event scheduled for October 21 st
• Property for Sale Update — No formal offers had been received for EDA properties
(Fred's Auto, 4th Street, Cedar Street garden center).
13. Adiournme
BILL TAPPER MOVED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 6:44 PM. TOM
PERRAULT AND JIM DAVIDSON SECONDED THE MOTION. MOTION
CARRIED 7 -0.
Recorder: Kerry Burri
Approved:
Attest:
EDA Representative
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
5. Consideration of approving payment of bills (WO)
A. REFERENCE AND BACKGROUND:
Accounts Payable summary statements listing bills submitted during the previous
month are included for review.
B. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS:
1. Motion to approve payment of bills through October 2015.
2. Motion to approve payment of bills through October 2015 with changes as
directed by the EDA.
C. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends Alternative #1.
D. SUPPORTING DATA:
Accounts Payable Summary Statements
Accounts Payable
Transactions by Account
User: Debbie.Davidson
Printed: 10/07/2015 - 3:16PM
Batch: 00202.10.2015
Account Number
_ I OF
Vendor Description GL Date Check No Amount PO No
213 - 46301 - 430400
KENNEDY AND GRAVEN CHAR] General EDA Matters through 8/31/15 10/13/2015
114783
1,350.50
Vendor Subtotal for Dept:46301
1,350.50
213-46301-431990
WSB & ASSOCIATES INC BLK034 - Environmental Does - July! 10/13/2015
0
3,538.25
213 - 46301- 431990
WSB & ASSOCIATES INC BLK034 - Environmental Does 2015 10/13/2015
0
1,427.40
213 - 46301 - 431990
WSB & ASSOCIATES INC Economic Development & Market Ma 10/13/2015
0
4,000.00
Vendor Subtotal for Dept:46301
8,965.65
213 - 46301 - 431990
WILSON DEVELOPMENT SERVE Acquisition & Relocation Services -1\ 10/13/2015
0
303.00
213-46301-431990
WILSON DEVELOPMENT SERVII Acquisition & Relocation Services - I 10/13/2015
0
595.00
Vendor Subtotal for Dept:46301
898.00
213 - 46301 - 443300
INITIATIVE FOUNDATION 2015 Endowment Contribution 10/13/2015
114777
2,250.00
Vendor Subtotal for Dept:46301
2,250.00
213 - 46529 - 430400
KENNEDY AND GRAVEN CHAR] TIF 1 -29 - Services through 8/31/15 10/13/2015
114783
462.50
Vendor Subtotal for Dept:46529
462.50
Subtotal for Fund: 213
13,926.65
AP- Transactions by Account (10/07/2015 - 3:16 PM)
Page 1
Account Number
Vendor
Description
The preceding list of bills payable was reviewed and approved for payment.
Date: 11/18/2015 Approved by
Tracy Hinz - Treasurer
GL Date Check No
Report Total:
Amount PO No
13,926.65
AP- Transactions by Account (10/07/2015 - 3:16 PM) Page 2
Accounts Payable
Transactions by Account
User: Debbie.Davidson
Printed: 10/21/2015 - 1:19PM
Batch: 00203.10.2015
Account Number
Vendor
Description
CITY *0 F
M-o-iif i(eRo
GL Date Check No
213-46301-431990 NORTHLAND SECURITIES INC EDA -Special Tax Levy Authority - Si 10/27/2015
Vendor Subtotal for Dept:46301
The preceding list of bills payable was reviewed and approved for payment.
Date: 11/18/2015 Approved by
Tracy Hinz - Treasurer
Subtotal for Fund: 213
Report Total:
114854
Amount PO No
165.00
165.00
165.00
165.00
AP- Transactions by Account (10/21/2015 - 1:19 PM) Page 1
Accounts Payable
Transactions by Account
User: Debbie.Davidson
Printed: 11/02/2015 - 10:18AM
Batch: 00215.10.2015
Account Number
Vendor Description
Moiiifcello
GL Date Check No Amount PO No
213 - 46522- 438100 XCEL ENERGY ZCULPS - 51- 0623082 -8 - FDA 10/31/2015 0 17.09
Vendor Subtotal for Dept:46522 17.09
The preceding list of bills payable was reviewed and approved for payment.
Date: 11/18/2015 Approved by
Tracy Hinz - Treasurer
Subtotal for Fund: 213 17.09
Report Total: 17.09
AP- Transactions by Account (11/02/2015 - 10:18 AM) Page 1
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
6. Consideration of Market Matching report.
A. REFERENCE AND BACKGROUND:
A verbal report will be provided by WSB Market Matching consultant John Uphoff.
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
7. Consideration of properties for sale update
A. REFERENCE AND BACKGROUND:
Staff will provide a verbal report updating the status of properties for sale.
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
8. Consideration to approve a License Agreement between the EDA and the City of
Monticello for use of 201 and 249 East Broadway and a portion of 100 East Broadway
for City Proiect 100009 /Intersection of CSAH 75 /TH 25. (AS)
A. REFERENCE AND BACKGROUND:
The EDA is asked to consider granting a temporary license to the City of Monticello for
public infrastructure purposes. The subject property for the license agreement is 201/249
East Broadway (the western -most parcel of the former Cedar Street Garden Center site)
and 100 East Broadway.
A license agreement between the EDA and City is sought in order to allow for storage of
equipment and materials by the City's awarded contractor during the construction of
intersection improvements at CSAH 75 /TH 25. The City Engineer has indicated that due
to the relatively confined area for the project, these publicly -owned properties can provide
the necessary space for staging and storage during construction, including machinery,
vehicles and materials.
The contractors and subcontractors will be required to restore both sites to existing
condition. This requirement is included in the language for the license. In addition, this
license does not impact the license agreement in place for use of the paved area for parking
at 201 Cedar Street.
If the EDA is amenable to such a license agreement, the City will be asked to consider the
same.
Staff has suggested a sunset date of August 1 st, 2016 to coincide with the end of
construction for the intersection project.
Al. Budget Impact: No impact to EDA is anticipated. Finance Director will verify
insurance requirements as needed.
A2. Staff Impact: None.
B. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS:
1. Motion to approve a license agreement as described for 201 and 249 East Broadway
and a portion of 100 East Broadway for City Project 100009 /Intersection of CSAH 75 /TH
25.
2. Motion of other.
C. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends Alternative #1. The license agreement is a temporary condition to allow
the City areas for staging and storage associated with a public improvement project.
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
D. SUPPORTING DATA:
Aerial Site Image
Draft License Agreement
— 1:�l - '. -, - 1 0 l*PY I
qMk7
OAF,
114 4
C� r%l
. . . . . . . . . .
df
AL
a lit
lip, dw
—Mom
04''
ly
Od j� %6
fit
RAL
t
-6. FA
lit
411-
jp ft
6r
7in 4ki
ft
JIM
M if
4f If.
F,l zo I ILI
I,L-J I., ILI b 11
."j
.r 4114i
A
40
L�V&Ao�
LICENSE AGREEMENT
AGREEMENT made this 18th day of November, 2015, by and between the City of Monticello
Economic Development Authority, a public body corporate and politic and political subdivision of
the State of Minnesota ( "EDA ") and the City of Monticello, a Minnesota municipal corporation
( "City").
WITNESSETH
WHEREAS, the EDA is the owner of the properties located at 201 East Broadway Street, PID
155010067010, 249 East Broadway Street, PID 155010067060, and 100 Broadway East, PID
155010034150, in the City, as described and hereto attached as Exhibit A (the "Subject Property ").
WHEREAS, the City desires to obtain a license over and across a portion of the Subject
Property for staging, storage, and mobilization operations associated with City Improvement Project
100009 for improvements to the intersection of CSAH 75 /TH 25 (the "Permitted Uses ").
WHEREAS, the EDA has agreed to allow the City to enter onto the Subject Property for the
Permitted Uses in accordance with the terms and conditions of this Agreement.
NOW THEREFORE, the parties agree as follows:
1. The EDA does hereby grant to the City, its employees, agents and contractors (the "Authorized
Parties "), a non - exclusive, non - transferable license to use the Subject Property for the Permitted
Uses. The Authorized Parties shall have access to the Property seven (7) days a week between
the hours of 5:00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m.
2. Nothing in this Agreement shall prohibit the EDA from the use of the Subject Property for
public purposes.
3. The City shall be responsible for all costs relating to construction, reconstruction, maintenance,
signage, and repair and restoration, including snow removal, with respect to the Subject
Property during the license period (the "Maintenance "). The Maintenance is a personal
obligation of the City and shall be binding upon the executors, administrators, successors, heirs
and assigns of the City.
4. The City agrees to indemnify, save harmless, and defend the EDA, its officers, and employees,
from and against any and all claims, actions, damages, liability and expense in connection with
personal injury and/or damage to the Subject Property arising from or out of any occurrence in,
470614v2 MNI MN190 -101
upon or at the Subject Property caused by the act or omission of the Authorized Parties in
conducting the Permitted Uses on the Subject Property, and will, at the City's own cost and
expense, defend any and all suits or actions (just or unjust) which may be brought against the
EDA or in which the EDA may be impleaded with others upon any such above - mentioned matter,
claim, or claims. This indemnity and hold harmless provision will include indemnity against all
costs, expenses, and liabilities incurred in or in connection with any such claims or proceedings
brought thereon and the defense thereof.
The City shall not permit any mechanics', materialmens' or other liens to stand against the
Subject Property or any part thereof for work or materials furnished to the City in connection
with the Permitted Uses granted pursuant to this Agreement and the City agrees to indemnify,
defend and hold harmless the EDA from and against the same.
6. The EDA, at its sole option, may terminate this Agreement upon 30 days' written notice to the
City.
7. This Agreement shall expire on August l st, 2016 unless sooner terminated pursuant to paragraph 6.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned have executed this Agreement the day and year
first above written.
CITY OF MONTICELLO ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
I:
RIM
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss
COUNTY OF WRIGHT )
Bill Demeules, President
Jeff O 'Neill, Executive Director
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this _ day of
, 2015, by Bill Demeules, President of the City of Monticello Economic Development
Authority, a public body corporate and politic and political subdivision of the State of Minnesota, on
behalf of the political subdivision.
NOTARY PUBLIC
470614v2 MNI MN190 -101
STATE OF MINNESOTA)
( ss
COUNTY OF WRIGHT)
CITY OF MONTICELLO
Brian Stumpf, Mayor
Jeff ONeill, City Administrator
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this _ day of , 2015, by
Brian Stumpf and by Jeff ONeill, the Mayor and City Administrator of the City of Monticello, a
Minnesota municipal corporation, on behalf of the corporation and pursuant to the authority granted by
its City Council.
NOTARY PUBLIC
470614v2 MNI MN190 -101
EXHIBIT A
Lots 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5, Block B, Original Plat of Monticello, County of Wright, Minnesota
and
Lots 14 and 15, Block 34, Original Plat of Monticello, County of Wright, Minnesota
470614v2 MNI MN190 -101
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
9. Consideration of an update on the status and iob description for the Economic
Development staff position. (AS)
A. REFERENCE AND BACKGROUND:
The City Council approved the hiring of a full -time economic development staff person for
2016 on November 9th. The position was posted the week of November 9th, following
Council approval. The position posting will be open for three weeks. The EDA and Council
will both be involved in the interview and selection process. The goal is to have a staff person
on board in early January.
The job description for the position is substantially similar to that reviewed by the ad -hoc
EDA sub - committee of Lloyd Hilgart and Jim Davidson and recommended by the EDA in
August. In finalizing the job description for hiring, a few minor updates were made. First,
the "Executive Director" function of the EDA, which was been held by the City Administrator
since 2012, is proposed to be shifted back to the economic development position. Second, the
position title has been changed to "Manager" rather than "Coordinator ". These two changes
are made in recognition of the responsibilities and work tasks associated with the position.
The role is one which includes a good deal of discretion and professional accountability.
Lastly, the position will continue to report to the Community Development Director, as was
the case with the previous position and staff.
In December, the EDA will be asked to take action relating to the termination or phase -out of
Market Matching services.
Al. Budget Impact: The annual salary range for this exempt position based on 2015 wage
benefit costs is $51,730 - $67,327, plus an additional $22,883 ($19,083 insurance and
PERA, and $3,800 taxes). The salary for the economic development position will be
paid from the HRA levy.
A2. Staff Impact: Hire of an economic development staff position will create a re-
alignment of workload for the City Administrator, Finance Director and Community
Development Director.
B. ALTERNATIVE ACTIONS:
Comments and feedback requested at this time; no formal action required.
C. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff continues to support the hiring of an economic development staff position to facilitate a
more proactive approach to economic development for the community and a better use of
time and monetary resources for economic development efforts.
D. SUPPORTING DATA:
Draft Job Description
Economic Development Manager
City of Monticello
Exempt
Title of Class: Economic Development Manager
Effective Date: November 15, 1991
Revised Date: October 13, 2008
February 11, 2011
October 27th, 2015
DESCRIPTION OF DUTIES
General Statement of Duties: Performs responsible professional work, planning, promoting,
developing and implementing economic development and redevelopment goals for the City; performs
related duties as required. Generates business leads, promotes business retention and expansion,
creates a positive attitude for development and raises supportive public awareness for strategic
economic planning and development.
Supervision Received: Works under the general supervision of the Community Development
Director with additional work direction provided by the City Administrator.
Supervision Exercised: None.
TYPICAL DUTIES PERFORMED
The listed examples may not include all duties performed by all positions in this class. Duties may
vary somewhat from position to position within a class.
ADMINISTRATION
*Provides administrative and professional support to the EDA as the EDA Executive Director,
managing business affairs, agenda and minutes, and acting as the staff liaison for the City.
In conjunction with the Finance Director, oversees the Authority's budget, financial and fund
reports.
*Plans, develops, presents for approval, and implements long range goals and strategies which
support the City Council and EDA goals as reflected in the Monticello Comprehensive Plan and
Monticello Redevelopment Project No. 1 Plan.
*Oversees, develops, markets, administers, and evaluates financial funding strategies and business
subsidy and incentive programs which support the City's goals
*Ensures compliance and performs required reporting in accordance with the MN Business Subsidy
Act, State Auditor's requirements and applicable federal regulations.
*Provides city staff with reports and recommendations on development proposals and assists in
identifying site development issues for economic development projects.
Maintains all business records and reporting requirements for the Economic Development
Department and EDA.
*Primary staff liaison to the Industrial and Economic Development Committee, Chamber of
Commerce, Wright County Economic Development Partnership, Economic Development
Association of MN and MN Department of Employment & Economic Development.
Prepares annual business report for the EDA, completes required forms and publishes notices.
Assists in preparing and updating economic development and redevelopment portions of the
City's comprehensive plan in cooperation with Community Development Department and
provides input on other aspects of the plan.
Economic Development Manager
City of Monticello
Exempt
*Facilitates and prepares the annual Economic Development Work Plan in conjunction with the
Community Development Director and assists in the development and monitoring of the annual
budget.
Monitors legislative initiatives related to economic development and redevelopment which may
impact the EDA and City.
Coordinates the work of City consultants as related to economic development initiatives, including
legal and financial services.
May assist in preparation of grant applications.
Performs other duties as needed or assigned.
BUSINESS & DEVELOPMENT RELATIONS
*Maintains regular contact with business and property owners, developers, real estate agents, lending
institutions, and related organizations to facilitate achievement of economic development goals
and business retention and expansion efforts.
*Assists developers with preliminary and formal business subsidy applications, analyzes formal
application and financial information and prepares written recommendation for EDA and
Council approval.
*Negotiates terms and conditions for TIF Districts, purchase agreements, development contracts, loan
agreements, land acquisitions and sales, assessment agreements, and other related documents
with assistance from the EDA's attorney and as directed by the EDA.
MARKETING & SALES
*Prepares, organizes and implements a coordinated marketing program to generate business
and industry leads which are consistent with the City's economic development goals.
*Serves as primary City liaison at prospect stage, assisting in developing, preparing and presenting
individualized project financing proposals in cooperation with City consultants to meet
prospects' financing requirements.
*Participates in the citywide marketing/branding effort.
*Maintains and distributes updated marketing and sales information pertaining to economic
development including: community profile, demographic and employment data, building
and land inventories and contacts, City /EDA property information and sales sheets, and
prospect databases.
*Plans and oversees marketing for City -owned business center and other EDA /City properties.
Participates in exhibitions, seminars, media events, trade shows and conferences to attract
businesses to the City.
Organizes events, meetings and activities supporting economic development initiatives, including
trainings, industry recognitions, and familiarization tours.
KNOWLEDGE, SHILLS AND ABILITIES
*Considerable knowledge of government processes and services, economic research and marketing
related to economic development and redevelopment.
*Considerable knowledge of city planning, project development, financing, land acquisition and
related areas.
*Working knowledge of laws, rules and regulations related to development and related financing and
ability to communicate such to industrial project developers.
*Considerable skill to operate office equipment including personal computer with Internet, word
processing, spreadsheet, Power Point and database management applications.
Economic Development Manager
City of Monticello
Exempt
*Considerable ability to communicate effectively both orally and in writing and maintain effective
working relationships with state and federal agencies, property and businesses owners, elected
and appointed officials, committee members, potential developers and the general public.
*Considerable ability to develop alternatives and determine costs, advantages and disadvantages of
various alternatives.
*Considerable ability to analyze financial statements including balance sheets, profit and loss sheets
and cash flow statements.
Working ability to read and interpret building plans, site plans and city service maps.
MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS
Bachelor's degree with major course work in economic development, local and urban affairs,
planning or a related field and five years of experience in economic or community development.
Certification from the National Development Council preferred.
Must possess and maintain a valid MN Class D Driver's license.
*Asterisked items are essential to the job
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
10. Economic Development Report (JO /AS)
TIF 1 -22, Pooling for Housing
On October 26th, 2015, the City Council approved a resolution in support of the modification
to TIF 1 -22 to allow additional pooling in TIF 1 -22 for housing purposes.
With this action, the EDA will now begin to pool separate increment, 10% of increment
collected, for housing activities in TIF 1 -22. The annual calculation for return of excess tax
increment will be adjusted accordingly.
Update on Block 34
The additional boring was taken on the property known as Finders Keepers, as requested by
the MPCA. The EDA will recall that the MPCA had requested an additional boring south of
those taken on the EDA property on Block 34 in order to determine the limits of
contamination found at the 100 East Broadway site.
The boring test results from Finders Keepers indicated that petroleum -based compound levels
were below MPCA thresholds. As such, WSB will be preparing the final LSI documentation
and requesting site closure to the MPCA. Removal of contaminated soils on 100 East
Broadway in the turn lane area will occur with the CSAH 73 /TH 25 project, anticipated to
occur April — June 2016. Funding for remediation will be included within the project costs.
WSB is preparing a scope of work for determining potential coal gasification- related
contamination on "The Zoo" property. The scope will be brought forward at a future EDA
meeting for consideration.
Update on TIF 1 -35
Staff has consulted with the developer and EDA attorney regarding options for TIF 1 -35. It
appears that the developer does retain all 26 years of increment collection under the TIF plan.
In addition, the attorney has indicated that the EDA, at its discretion, may consider a minor
modification of the TIF plan to allow for a variation to the type of project developed in the
TIF district. In addition, the EDA's financial consultant has recommended a modification to
the TIF plan to more accurately reflect actual expenses within budget line items. The attorney
had recommended that the TIF modification occur at the time a project is ready to move
forward within the district in order to address any and all modifications necessary at that time.
However, if the EDA's desire is to allow the developer additional time in which to move a
project forward, the EDA can move forward with an amendment to the contract for private
redevelopment to adjust the commencement and completion dates at this time. This is in
alternative to declaration of default.
The above information was conveyed to the developer, who will be sending correspondence
to the EDA detailing a request for extension on commencement and completion dates for the
contract amendment.
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
TIF District 1 -36
This district will decertify at the end of 2015 automatically. TIF District 1 -36 is the Rocky
Mountain LLC (Dahlheimers) TIF District. Located in Otter Creek, the primary goal of the
district, as an economic development district, was to allow for the relocation and expansion of
an existing business, with the increment repaying the land write -down and development
expenses associated with Otter Creek.
Fred's Auto Storage
The City has requested that the Fred's Auto building be used for the temporary storage of
some of the City's vehicle fleet. During the winter months, a vehicle for the Community
Center and Building Dept. are infrequently used. Storage indoors is a better long -term option
for maintenance of the vehicles. It is understood that the storage is temporary and would be
required to be removed if a sale were to occur. Marketing of the site will not be impacted.
2
EDA Agenda: 11/18/15
11. Consideration of recessing to closed session to develop or consider offers or
counteroffers for the purchase or sale of real or personal property pursuant to
Minnesota Statute 13D.05(3)(C)(3)